Awhile back, I posted a question to the too-clever-for-their-own-good gang over at The Forge. Its the place you go to talk about indie games, or how to play games - and I mean 'how to play' them in the snooty Simpson's comic book guy voice.
I asked a simple question, and gave some context.
All of the answers completely ignored the question, and provided tons of feedback about my context.
Let me analogize: Let's say you post on a home repair website, "Hi, I'm replacing the garage door to my home, and I wonder if you would recommend brand A or brand B?"
And you receive some responses:
"Interesting project. Sounds like your home must be aging some. Have you checked to make sure that your roof is not leaking? A leaking roof can really kill your home, it causes all sorts of problems."
"When I'm replacing a garage door, one of the first things that I always do is mow the lawn. Why? Well because an unkempt lawn looks awful, and just drives me nuts!"
"Instead of replacing your garage door, have you considered tearing down your garage? You could convert it into a patio or a nice garden."
I even posted a followup, to point out that no one was really addressing my question, and that the context was just that - context. To which my replies were like this:
"Well, I don't understand why you are not concerned about your roof. Doesn't sound like wise planning to me!"
Gee, imagine that. Someone on the internet needs punching, AGAIN!
Nit picking over pregenerated characters. I'm running a game with pregens. Thusfar I've had almost no problems, everyone is fine with playing what I've handed them. Except one dude, who wants to nit pick over it, and then when I'm less than willing to start changing stuff (or letting him play characters that are not available), he's not interested. Good riddance.